The Class That Feels Hard on Day One
“A misbehaving child is a discouraged child.”
— Rudolf Dreikurs
Sometimes you just know.
It might be the first morning, or perhaps the first week, when you begin to notice that this particular class is going to require something different from you.
They are noisy. They talk over one another. There is more arguing than you expected. Transitions take forever. One child seems to challenge every instruction and another disappears into their own world whenever you ask them to join in.
You find yourself going home thinking: How am I going to manage this class?
It is such an understandable thought, particularly when you have just spent months imagining a fresh start. You want the new school year to feel positive. You want to establish routines early. You want everyone to know what is expected.
And then you meet this class.
I think one of the hardest things about a difficult start is how quickly we can begin telling ourselves a story about the children:
They are difficult.
They do not listen.
They are attention-seeking.
They are going to be hard work all year.
Once that story settles in our minds, everything they do can begin to look like evidence that we were right.
The child who calls out is interrupting again. The child who refuses to join in is being difficult again. The child who keeps wandering around the classroom is deliberately ignoring instructions again.
But what happens when we become curious instead?
Not How do I stop this behaviour? but What is this behaviour telling me?
That small shift can change an entire classroom.
Perhaps the child who constantly calls out is struggling to wait for their turn because they are desperate to be noticed.
Perhaps the child who refuses to participate is worried about getting something wrong in front of everyone.
Perhaps the child who keeps leaving their seat finds transitions overwhelming and does not yet know how to manage them.
We cannot know simply by looking at the behaviour. We have to ask.
This is where one of the most useful ideas in Positive Discipline becomes practical: look for the mistaken belief underneath the behaviour rather than simply reacting to what is on the surface.
It doesn’t mean excusing the behaviour. It means becoming interested in what the child may be trying to achieve through it.
Imagine a child who repeatedly interrupts you. After the third interruption, you might be tempted to say, “You clearly don't understand that other people need a turn.”
You can pause and speak to them privately later and ask questions like:
“I've noticed you have a lot to say during our discussions. What makes it difficult to wait for your turn?”
Maybe they are afraid they will forget their thought. Maybe they feel that nobody listens unless they speak quickly. Maybe they simply have not yet developed the skill of waiting.
Now you have something you can actually work with.
You might agree on a signal they can use when they have something to contribute. You might give them a place to jot their thoughts down. You might practise taking turns with them rather than repeatedly telling them to stop interrupting.
The behaviour has not magically disappeared. But your response has changed from How do I make this child stop? to How can I help this child learn a different way?
That difference matters. And it matters especially when you are dealing with a whole class that feels difficult.
Because when we are overwhelmed, we can become very focused on control.
We tighten the rules. We repeat instructions more loudly. We add consequences. We spend more and more energy trying to make the classroom behave the way we think it should.
Learn the children's names quickly. Find out what they love. Notice who is funny, who is quiet, who needs extra time, who always wants to help, who seems confident but becomes anxious when work gets difficult. Let them see that you are interested in them beyond whether they are following instructions.
Then, when something goes wrong, you are not responding to a collection of behaviours. You are responding to children you know.
And that makes a difficult class feel different. It also gives us somewhere to go when our first approach does not work.
Because sometimes the strategy that worked beautifully last year will completely flop with this group
Q-TIPS: Quick Tips When Things Feel Difficult
1. Change the questions
Instead of “What's wrong with this class?” try “What's happening here?” Curiosity can open up possibilities that labels close down.
2. Look for what is working
Even on a difficult day, notice one thing that went well. Small successes are worth noticing and building on.
3. Separate the child from the behaviour
Instead of “He is difficult,” try “He is finding this difficult right now.” It leaves room for change.
4. Create opportunities to succeed together
Give the class something simple to accomplish collaboratively. Shared success can begin to shift a difficult classroom dynamic.
5. Have the private conversation
When possible, speak to a struggling child privately rather than correcting them publicly. Sometimes connection is the first step toward understanding the behaviour.
We simply cannot know the whole story on day one. So if your class feels hard already, try not to write the ending yet.
Instead of seeing a behaviour as a fixed characteristic, see it as information. And instead of trying to win every difficult moment, look for the opportunity to teach the skill that the child does not have yet.
Because the class in front of you on the first day is not a finished product, and neither are you.
You are all still learning each other. And sometimes that is where the most important work of the school year begins.
I want to leave you with something practical for those conversations.
Small Talk: 101 Conversation Cards for Deeper Connection is now available to order.
If this month's series has reminded you of the value of real conversation, I'd love to share something I created with that in mind designed to spark meaningful, screen-free conversations, these cards help turn ordinary moments into memorable ones.
Because sometimes, all it takes is one good question.
Pre-order now at joymarchese.com/shop.
Do you want to bring us directly to your school or organization ?
From leadership teams to full faculty, we offer customized workshops that equip educators to integrate SEL and Educational Neuroscience seamlessly into everyday teaching.
💡 Let’s partner to build stronger, more connected school communities—together.
